Stephen J. Birchard DVM, MS, Diplomate ACVS

Sunday, January 20, 2019

4 Common Mistakes Made When Using Surgical Instruments

One of the most fundamental of surgical skills is proper handling of instruments. Using surgical instruments improperly can make the surgical procedure more difficult and time consuming. Here are 4 mistakes commonly made by inexperienced surgeons, and how to fix them:

1. Needle holders: the instrument is held with the thumb and 4th finger, but there is a right and wrong way to do it (it's all in the thumb!) This also applies to any forceps or scissors with ringed handles. (Fig. 1)
Fig 1a: Incorrect method to hold needle holders or any forceps or scissors
with ringed handles. Note how the thumb is too far inside the ring.
Fig 1b: Correct method to hold needle holders. Note that the only the tip
of the thumb is inserted through the ring of the instrument.

2. Thumb forceps: how the forceps are held can make a world of difference. (Figure 2)
Fig 2a: Incorrect method for holding thumb tissue forceps. This is a
clumsy grip that results in greater tissue trauma. 
Fig 2b: Correct and more precise method for holding tissue forceps. 

3. Retractors: holding them properly will avoid having the assistant's hand obscure the surgical field. (Fig. 3)
Fig. 3a: These are Senn retractors, commonly used in veterinary surgery.
Fig. 3b: Incorrect grip on the retractor. The fingers are too close  to
the end of the retractor resulting in the fingers and hand interfering with
the surgical exposure.
Fig. 3c: Correct grip on the retractor which will keep the fingers away from the
surgical field.

4. Cutting suture ends after tying a knot: here's a hint, use the tips! (Fig. 4)
Fig. 4a: Incorrect method of cutting suture ends with  scissors.
The blades close to the hinge are being used to cut the suture which
obscures the knot, making it difficult to see how long the suture ends will be. 
Figure 4b: Correct method; using the scissor's tips allow the assistant
to see the distance between the knot and the length being cut.
I hope you find these suggestions helpful. Post any questions or comments you may have on instrument handling and technique.

Tuesday, September 18, 2018

How To Repair Diaphragmatic Hernias in Dogs and Cats

   Hernias of the diaphragm can be either congenital or acquired. Acquired hernias are most commonly due to blunt trauma to the abdomen.  Increased intra-abdominal pressure causes the diaphragm to stretch and rupture.  Liver, spleen and intestines are the organs most commonly herniated into the thoracic cavity.(1)  The muscular portion of the diaphragm, at its ventral and lateral aspects, is the most frequently torn area. Congenital hernias include the pericardial peritoneal diaphragmatic hernia (PPDH).

   Clinical Signs  
   Signs of respiratory distress, e.g., tachypnea, dyspnea, or abdominal breathing, are most common.  The animal may have a "tucked-up" appearance to the abdomen due to shifting of viscera into the pleural space.  In chronic cases, weight loss and lethargy may be the only signs the owners describe.(2) Exercise intolerance is also usually seen. In rare cases, the owner may describe signs referable to other organ systems.  For example, herniation of the intestine can cause obstruction of bowel, resulting in vomiting.  Herniation of the liver and biliary system can cause extrahepatic biliary obstruction, causing elevated serum bilirubin and icterus. 
   Auscultation of the thorax reveals decreased lung sounds ventrally, and muffled heart sounds.  The thorax is dull on percussion.  Reportedly, auscultation of borborygmus in the thorax is a sign of diaphragmatic hernia, but this is not a consistent finding and should not be depended upon to make the diagnosis.
   Radiographic examination of the thorax may reveal fluid densities and/or bowel loops in the thorax. (Fig 1) Loss of continuity of the diaphragm is also seen. 
Fig. 1: Lateral thoracic radiograph of a dog with a diaphragmatic hernia and
several loops of bowel in the thoracic cavity. 
Hydrothorax may be the only radiographic sign if the liver is the only organ herniated into the thorax.  This fluid appears serosanguineous and is a transudate or modified transudate.  Ultrasonographic examination of the cranial abdomen can help confirm the hernia. 
   Preoperative Care  
   Diaphragmatic herniorraphy is usually considered an emergency operation. Although historically some authors advocated delaying surgical repair for several hours (3), a more recent study found that patients operated within the first 24 hours after presentation had very good outcomes (90% survival) (4). If the animal with diaphragmatic hernia does not stabilize with initial supportive care or if stomach or strangulated bowel is in the thorax the repair must be done immediately.(5) Stomach in the thorax can become dilated with air and cause life threatening hypoventilation. (Fig. 2) 
Fig. 2: Lateral thoracic radiograph of a dog with diaphragmatic hernia and stomach in the thorax cavity.
The stomach is severely dilated with air. 
If this occurs, pass a stomach tube to initially decompress the stomach If a stomach tube cannot be passed perform gastrocentesis percutaneously by placing a needle or over the needle catheter into the stomach through the chest wall.  When respiratory parameters have improved, anesthesia and surgery can then be performed.
   Since these patients have markedly reduced ventilatory capacity, anesthetic induction and intubation must be rapid and smooth.  Pre-oxygenation of the patient in an oxygen cage or with an anesthetic mask is helpful to prevent hypoxia during the stress of anesthetic induction.  Rapidly acting intravenous induction agents, such as propofol, allow prompt intubation.  Begin positive pressure ventilation as soon as the endotracheal tube is placed.  Inhalant anesthetics, such as isoflurane, are acceptable for maintenance of anesthesia.
   During the clipping and prepping of the animal for surgery, the prep table can be tilted so that the head is elevated and the hindquarters lowered.  This helps prevent movement of abdominal viscera into the thorax.  
   Key Point: It is important to realize that when the abdominal cavity is surgically opened in an animal with diaphragmatic hernia, the animal will no longer be able to ventilate on its own. The rent in the diaphragm allows air to enter the thoracic cavity when the abdomen is open, eliminating the negative intrathoracic pressure that is necessary for normal ventilation. Intermittent positive pressure ventilation (IPPV) is therefore necessary during the surgical repair of the diaphragm. 
   The ventral midline abdominal approach is indicated for most diaphragmatic hernias. (Fig. 3) 
Fig. 3: Intraoperative appearance of a left diaphragmatic hernia
exposed via a ventral midline abdominal approach.
(arrows indicate edges of the ruptured diaphragm).
The liver is present in the thoracic cavity.
Balfour retractors and large malleable retractors facilitate the exposure.  Grasping the edges of the diaphramatic defect with Babcock forceps or stay sutures can help in closure of the defect.  In many cases, the diaphragmatic defect must be enlarged to allow the viscera to be pulled back (reduced) into the abdomen.  When enlarging the defect, be sure to make the diaphragmatic incision in an accessible portion of the diaphragm to simplify closure. Chronic hernias may be associated with adhesions between the herniated organs and the lungs or mediastinum.(2) Break these down carefully to avoid injury to lung or other organs.  After reducing herniated organs back to the abdominal cavity carefully examine the lungs for evidence of atelectasis.  If atelectasis is found it is best not to acutely re-expand those lung lobes since re-expansion pulmonary edema can occur.  This is especially true in chronic hernias.  Place a thoracic drain tube before closure of the diaphragm to allow for re-establishment of negative pressure in the pleural space once the diaphragmic rent is repaired.  
   A variety of techniques for herniorrhaphy have been described.  The author prefers a continuous suture pattern using 2-0 or 3-0 PDS depending on patient size. Suturing is begun at the most inaccessible area of the defect (usually the dorsal aspect) progressing to the most accessible.(Fig 4) 
Fig. 4: Same dog as in figure 3 after suture closure of the diaphragmatic hernia.
Be very careful when working around the central part of the diaphragm because of the caudal vena cava.  Take care to not make the closure too tight around the caval hiatus.  Incorporation of the ribs with the soft tissues during suturing is sometimes necessary for those hernias that occur along the costal arch.
   In rare cases there is not enough diaphragmatic tissue to permit primary closure.  For example, chronic hernias in which the diaphragmatic tissue tears directly off the costal arch or dorsally from the spine.  In these cases reconstruction of the defect with a mesh implant such as Marlex mesh can be used.  The mesh is sutured in place with non-absorbable sutures such as monofilament polypropylene.  Prophylactic antibiotics are indicated in these cases.
   Once closure of the diaphragm is completed, remove residual air from the thorax.  This can be done either directly through the diaphragm using a needle or over the needle catheter or by placing a thoracostomy tube. When postoperative pneumothorax is a potential problem, such as those cases with lung adhesions, an indwelling thoracic drain tube should be placed and left in for as long as necessary to ensure stable negative intrapleural pressure. As previously mentioned in animals with chronic hernias and lung atelectasis, slowly evacuate the air in the pleural space over several hours to prevent re-expansion pulmonary edema. 
   Postoperative Care 
   Close observation of the patient is mandatory postoperatively.  If available the patient is kept in an oxygen cage until recovered.  In most cases recovery is unremarkable.  Acute, severe pulmonary edema can occur in some animals postoperatively and must be treated aggressively using diuretics, oxygen, and assisted ventilation.  In general the prognosis for postoperative survival is very good for patients with either acute or chronic diaphragmatic hernias. (2,4)
1. Wilson GP, Newton CD, Burt JK. A review of 116 diaphragmatic hernias in dogs and cats. J Am Vet Med Assoc 1971; 159:1142-1145
2. Minihan AC, Berg J, Evans KL. Chronic diaphragmatic hernia in 34 dogs and 16 cats.
J Am Anim Hosp Assoc. 2004 Jan-Feb;40(1):51-63. 
3. Boudrieau RJ: Pathophysiology of Traumatic Diaphragmatic Hernia, in Bojrab MJ (ED): Disease Mechanisms in  Small Animal Surgery, ed 2. Philadelphia, Lea & Febiger, 1993, pgs 103–108
4. Gibson TW1, Brisson BA, Sears W. Perioperative survival rates after surgery for diaphragmatic hernia in dogs and cats: 92 cases (1990-2002).J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2005 Jul 1;227(1):105-9.
5.Bjorling DE. Thoracic Trauma, in Birchard SJ, Sherding RG, ed. Saunders Manual of Small Animal Practice. St. Louis, Elsevier, 2006, pgs. 1721-1722.

Thursday, May 31, 2018

Do Lawn Treatment Chemicals Cause Cancer in Pets? A growing body of research says yes!

Cancer is one of the most important health issues affecting household pets. Causes of cancer are many and varied, including genetic predispositions, certain viruses, and exposure to environmental toxins. Many studies in both humans and animals have focused on the increased risk of cancer from chronic use of chemicals such as pesticides and herbicides around the household.  Since dogs and cats have significant exposure to grassy areas of properties, lawn chemicals in particular have been studied for the potential of causing health problems.

Several studies have now shown an association between the frequently used chemicals on household lawns and cancer in dogs.(1-4) Dogs chronically exposed to the herbicides and pesticides in lawn sprays and granules are more likely to get cancers such as lymphoma and transitional cell carcinoma of the urinary bladder. An initial study published in the Journal of the National Cancer Institute in 1991 found that homeowners that frequently used the herbicide 2,4- dichlorophenoxyacetic acid on their lawn had a statistically significant higher rate of lymphosarcoma in their dogs.(1) Lymphosarcoma, also called malignant lymphoma, is a common cancer affecting lymph nodes and other organs and lymphatic tissues. This study was heavily criticized by other investigators who questioned the validity of the results. However, a more recent study published in 2012 analyzed 263 dogs with lymphosarcoma and found a 70% increase in risk of the cancer in households with professionally applied pesticides on the lawns.(2)

Two studies at Purdue University College of Veterinary Medicine have also found disturbing results of dogs exposed to herbicides, particularly the phenoxy herbicides such as the previously mentioned 2,4- dichlorophenoxyacetic acid, also called 2,4-D.(3,4) 

Herbicides were found in the urine of 76% of dogs from households that used them on their lawn.(4) The herbicides were also found in the urine of some dogs from households where the herbicide was not used, indicating they were exposed to them in areas other than their own property. 

The additional study from Purdue found that Scottish Terriers living in households that used herbicides alone or herbicides and pesticides on their lawns were markedly more prone to transitional cell carcinoma of the urinary bladder.(3) This study, along with the former one looking at the chemicals being present in the urine, are convincing evidence that the herbicide exposure is directly related to bladder cancer in this breed. Other breeds could be examined in the future to further define the risks of exposure. 

More research is needed to elaborate the dangers of lawn chemicals to our pets, but these well designed and executed studies make it clear that the commonly used pesticides and herbicides being indiscriminately sprayed and broadcast on our lawns are causing cancer in dogs. Many provinces in Canada have completely banned what they call “cosmetic” use of herbicides and pesticides because of the potential health problems. Cosmetic is a good term because the cancer causing chemicals are being used merely to improve the appearance of our lawns. Maybe we should be more tolerant of less than perfect grass if it decreases the adverse health effects on our pets. 

Although additional studies will help to better define the problem, we now have sufficient evidence to raise serious concerns about the dangers of herbicides and pesticides used on lawns. Homeowners should be educated about these issues so that they can take appropriate action to protect their pets from harm. Professional lawn care companies also need to carefully consider their protocols and make necessary changes to stop contaminating the environment with chemicals that are now proven to be carcinogenic to pets. 


1. Hayes HM1, Tarone RE, Cantor KP, Jessen CR, McCurnin DM, Richardson RC. Case-control study of canine malignant lymphoma: positive association with dog owner's use of 2,4- dichlorophenoxyacetic acid herbicides. J Natl Cancer Inst. 1991 Sep 4;83(17):1226-31. 

2. Biki B. Takashima-Uebelhoer, Lisa G. Barber, Sofija E. Zagarins, Elizabeth Procter- 
Gray, Audra L. Gollenberg, Antony S. Moore, and Elizabeth R. Bertone-Johnson. Household Chemical Exposures and the Risk of Canine Malignant Lymphoma, a Model for Human Non-Hodgkin’s Lymphoma. Environ Res. 2012 January ; 112: 171–176. 

3. Glickman LT1, Raghavan M, Knapp DW, Bonney PL, Dawson MHJ. Herbicide exposure and the risk of transitional cell carcinoma of the urinary bladder in Scottish Terriers. J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2004 Apr 15;224(8):1290-7. 

4. Knapp DW1, Peer WA, Conteh A, Diggs AR, Cooper BR, Glickman NW, Bonney PL, Stewart JC, Glickman LT, Murphy AS. Detection of herbicides in the urine of pet dogs following home lawn chemical application. Sci Total Environ. 2013 Jul 1;456-457:34-41. 

Saturday, April 21, 2018

Axial Pattern Flap Reconstruction of a Chronic Non-Healing Elbow Wound in a Golden Retriever

Ginger is a 7-year-old female spayed golden retriever who presented to MedVet Toledo with a chronic non-healing open skin wound over the right elbow. (Fig. 1) 

Fig. 1: Ginger
The owner adopted Ginger 1.5 years prior to presentation and the wound was present at that time. Ginger was otherwise healthy with no major medical issues. Serous fluid drained from the wound occasionally. Antibiotic therapy previously prescribed did not result in significant improvement of the wound.

Physical examination of Ginger was normal except for a large (8cm diameter) open wound over the right elbow that appeared to be a decubital ulcer. (Fig. 2) 
Fig. 2: The non-healing chronic open wound over the right elbow on Ginger
Extensive fibrotic scar tissue was present around the periphery of the circular wound, and unhealthy granulation tissue was seen in the wound center. Little to no discharge was present on the wound surface.

A fine needle aspirate of the peripheral scar tissue was performed to rule out neoplasia and the cytology results indicated chronic inflammation. Routine preoperative CBC and serum chemistry profile were normal. The plan was to anesthetize Ginger, perform an extensive surgical debridement of the fibrotic peripheral tissues, and reconstruct the skin using an axial pattern skin flap. 

Ginger was anesthetized and the right elbow and surrounding skin clipped and prepared for aseptic surgery. The donut shaped abnormal scar tissue was removed using blunt and sharp dissection. (Fig. 3) 
Fig. 3: The right elbow of Ginger immediately after surgical debridement of the chronic wound. 
During this dissection it became clear that the tissue was highly vascularized. Hemostasis was difficult and bleeding became brisk throughout the dissected area. The hemorrhage was controlled with electrocautery and direct pressure. We elected to delay the skin flap reconstruction so that open wound management with tie-over bandages could be used on the elbow to allow the debrided area to be in more optimal condition for the definitive reconstruction procedure. (for more information see: tie-over bandages)

One week after the surgical debridement Ginger was re-admitted to the hospital for the skin flap procedure. Ginger was placed under general anesthesia and a thoracodorsal axial pattern skin flap was performed to reconstruct the elbow decubitalulcer. (Fig. 4)
(for more information see: axial pattern skin flaps
Fig. 4: Completed thoracodorsal axial pattern flap reconstruction of the elbow on Ginger.
White arrow indicates direction of transfer of the rectangular skin flap harvested from skin over the scapula.
Complete coverage of the wound was achieved with the skin flap. A spica bandage was placed over the leg and thorax to protect the incisions and Ginger was recovered from anesthesia. 

The following day Ginger’s bandage was changed and she was discharged from the hospital. Bandage changes occurred every 2-3 days until the incisions were healed and staples removed. (Fig. 5) 
Fig. 5: Appearance of the surgical incisions on Ginger 10 days postoperatively.
Ginger finally was discharged with no rechecks necessary unless problems arose. However 5 months later she represented to MedVet Toledo for problems unrelated to her elbow. The owner reported that since the skin flap reconstruction Ginger had been much more comfortable and mobile. Ginger’s skin flap had grown a thick, bushy amount of hair. There was redundant skin at the elbow but the overall cosmetic appearance was quite satisfactory. (Fig. 6) In general the owner was very pleased with the end result of the reconstruction.
Fig. 6: Appearance of Ginger's right elbow area 5 months after reconstruction.
Chronic wounds of the elbow in dogs are one of the most difficult to manage. Skin tension, excessive motion, and trauma to the area combine to interfere with healing in this part of the body. Debridement and local advancement of skin over the defect is generally unrewarding for reconstruction, particularly if it results in a suture line directly over the olecranon. Skin flap techniques that bring healthy, robust tissue into the site without creating a suture line over the olecranon, such as an axial pattern flap, is more likely to be successful.

Several aspects of the postoperative care are key to the success of this procedure. A well-padded bandage to protect and cushion the skin flap is mandatory for at least 10-14 days postoperatively. Exercise restriction is also important along with frequent postoperative rechecks to monitor for flap survival and healing. 

One clinical study of 10 dogs having thoracodorsal axial pattern flaps found complications to be common but good functional and cosmetic outcome resulted in 6 of 7 dogs long term follow up. (1)


1. Aper R, Smeak, D:  Complications and Outcome After Thoracodorsal Axial Pattern Flap Reconstruction of Forelimb Skin Defects in 10 Dogs, 1989–2001 32:4, 2003, Pages 378-384.

Sunday, December 31, 2017

How To Safely Place a Chest Tube in Dogs and Cats


Thoracic drain tubes are indicated for animals with disorders of the thoracic cavity  that cause accumulation of air or fluid in the pleural space. Some examples are: pneumothorax due to trauma or spontaneous causes such as emphysematous bullae, or pleural effusion due to infection (pyothorax) or neoplasia. If repeated drainage of the thorax is anticipated for palliative care of the patient, a thoracic drain is more effective and less painful for the patient than repeated thoracocentesis with a needle or catheter. A properly performed thoracic drain tube placement is a safe and effective means of managing patients with acute or chronic pleural disorders.


Basic surgical pack
Red rubber catheters (8 – 20 Fr),
or Argyle catheters with trocar (same sizes)
3-way stopcocks
Christmas tree adapters
Syringes (12 – 60mls)
Bandage materials
Antibiotic ointment
Suture material  (2-0 or 3-0 monofilament non-absorbable)

Place the animal under general anesthesia and prepare the lateral thorax for aseptic surgery. Make a small (2-3 cm) skin incision at the 10th intercostal space.
Incise through the subcutaneous tissue and the lattisimus dorsi muscle. Use a Carmalt or Pean forcep to create a tunnel underneath the lattisimus dorsi muscle from the skin incision to the 8th intercostal space. Grasp the tip of a red rubber catheter with a Carmalt forcep or use an Argyle trocar catheter. (Fig. 1)
Fig 1: The end of a red rubber catheter is grasped within a Carmalt clamp
from: Bateman SW, Emergency and Critical Care Techniques and Nutrition. 
In: Saunders Manual of Small Animal Practice. 3rd edition, 
Birchard and Sherding, eds., Elsevier, St. Louis, 2006. Pg. 29
Insert the tip of the tube into the skin incision and advance it through the tissue tunnel to the level of the 8th intercostal space.(Fig 2)
Fig. 2: The red rubber tube and Carmalt clamp are advanced from the 10th to the 8th intercostal space
Firmly grasp the tube and insert through the chest wall with a forceful but controlled effort. (Fig. 3)
Fig. 3: Cross sectional view of Carmalt clamp and chest tube entering the pleural cavity through the  intercostal space.
from: Bateman SW, Emergency and Critical Care Techniques and Nutrition. In: Saunders Manual of Small Animal Practice. 3rd edition, Birchard and Sherding, eds., Elsevier, St. Louis, 2006. Pg. 29
Once the tube has penetrated the chest wall, advance it into the pleural space. If using the Argyle tube, slide the trocar out of the tube and then slide the tube inside the pleural cavity.(Fig. 4)
Fig. 4: Sequence of steps(A-D) for inserting an Argyle thoracic drain tube with inner trocar into the chest cavity.
from: Crisp MS, Buffington CA. Critical Care Techniques. In: Saunders Manual of Small Animal Practice. 2nd edition, Birchard and Sherding, eds., Elsevier, St. Louis, 2000, pg. 21.
If using a red rubber catheter and forceps, after entering the chest open the forceps, slide the catheter into the pleural cavity, then remove the forceps from the incision. Promptly place a clamp on the tube after entering the chest to prevent pneumonthorax.

Place a 3-way stopcock on the end of the tube(Fig. 5); a Christmas tree adapter may be necessary to fit the stopcock to the flared end of the tube. 
Fig. 5: Stopcock secured to the end of the chest tube with wire; heavy
suture can also be used.
Use large suture or wire to secure the stopcock and adapter to the tube and place a purse string and finger trap pattern suture to secure the tube to the skin (Fig. 6).   
Fig. 6: Secure the thoracic drain tube to the skin with a purse string /finger trap suture combination.
A “C” clamp can also be placed on the tube for added safety in case the stopcock should become dislodged.  Apply antibiotic ointment to the tube entry site in the skin and protect the tube on the patient with a bandage.

Postoperative Care

Obtain radiographs of the thorax to ensure correct placement of the tube.(Fig. 7)
Fig. 7: Lateral thoracic radiograph of a cat with a thoracic drain tube in place.
Patients with thoracic drain tubes require 24 hour monitoring. If the tube becomes damaged or the stopcock is dislodged, immediate pneumothorax will occur and could be life threatening. Change the chest bandage as needed and check the tube location to be sure it is not pulling out and that the stopcock and Christmas tree adapter are tight and not leaking. Place an Elizabethan collar on the animal if necessary.

Evacuation of air and/or fluid can be performed either manually or with a continuous suction device which, when connected to a source of negative pressure, allows for drainage of the thoracic cavity. In most animals intermittent manual drainage of the chest cavity is sufficient to keep the animal’s respiratory status stable. 

In some cases a sudden increase in the amount of air being pulled from the drain tube can be due to a leak in the tube or its apparatus. Test the integrity of the tube by clamping the tube close to the patient and try applying negative pressure to the stopcock with a syringe. If air is easily withdrawn, a leak is present. Check all connections for tightness and check the tube for cracks or holes allowing air to leak into the system.

In addition to other routine supportive care measures, analgesic therapy with a NSAID or opioid such as Tramadol is indicated due to the painful nature of the indwelling tube in the pleural space. The pleura is one of the most sensitive tissues in the body and the tube acts as a foreign body rubbing on the pleural membranes. 

Thoracic drain tubes can be left in the patient for several days or even a few weeks at a time depending on the need for continued drainage. Since dogs do not have a complete mediastinum, a unilateral tube is usually adequate for drainage of both sides of the pleural cavity. However in some cases, such as chronic pyothorax or chylothorax, fibrinous adhesions in the cavity can make the fluid loculated, decreasing the function of the tube. Bilateral tubes may then be necessary.

Remove the chest tube when the amount of fluid or air is minimal. The chest tube acts as a foreign body in the pleural space and can create 1-2 mls/kg/24 hours of fluid. After removal of the tube apply antiobiotic ointment to the skin incision and keep the incision covered with a bandage for another 1-2 days.

The following is a video produced by my colleague Dr. Ron Bright demonstrating chest tube placement on a cadaver dog using an Argyle thoracic drain tube with trocar.


Bateman SW, Emergency and Critical Care Techniques and Nutrition. In: Saunders Manual of Small Animal Practice. 3rd edition, Birchard and Sherding, eds., Elsevier, St. Louis, 2006. Pg. 29

Tuesday, September 19, 2017

Should We Spay Dogs When Removing Mammary Tumors? This study answers that question.

V.M. Kristiansen, A. NĂždtvedt, A.M. Breen, et. al. Effect of ovariohysterectomy at the time of tumor removal in dogs with benign mammary tumors and hyperplastic lesions: A randomized controlled clinical trial 
J Vet Intern Med 2013;27:935–942 


The authors of this study sought to answer the following question: is there a clinical benefit to performing ovariohysterectomy (OHE) at the time of benign mammary tumor removal in dogs.  Their hypothesis was that removal of ovarian hormones by OHE would decrease the development of new benign mammary tumors and thus would have important clinical ramifications. In a randomized, controlled clinical trial, dogs having surgery to remove benign mammary tumors were placed in one of 2 groups: those also having OHE performed at the time of tumor removal (n=42), and those not having OHE performed (n=42). All tumors were analyzed by histopathology. The dogs were followed for at least 80 months and long term follow-up information obtained either by phone calls to owners or by recheck examinations by veterinarians. 

New benign mammary tumors developed in 64% of in tact dogs compared to 36% of dogs having OHE. This was statistically significant and showed the clinical benefit of concomitant OHE with benign mammary tumor removal. Nine of the intact dogs also went on to develop disorders of the ovaries or uterus, such as pyometra. There was no difference in survival data between the 2 groups. 


For years surgeons have recommended OHE in combination with removal of mammary tumors, not because of any proven benefit related to the mammary neoplasia, but to prevent other disorders such as pyometra. This study provides evidence of the benefit of performing OHE in combination with mammary tumor removal. The authors make the case that since dogs that develop benign mammary tumors are also at increased risk of developing malignant mammary tumors, prevention of future malignant tumors may also be a positive factor of OHE.

The lack of difference in survival between the two groups may be misleading since some of the dogs were euthanized. The many and varied issues surrounding the owner’s decision to euthanize make the survival data, in the author’s words, a “soft and biased endpoint in the study.” In contrast, the different rates of tumor recurrence between the 2 groups is objective data in which statistical significance was found.


This prospective randomized study provides objective evidence of the benefit of OHE in dogs being surgically treated for mammary tumors. Clinicians can recommend OHE at the time of mammary tumor removal as evidence based medicine approach to treatment, not just in the prevention of reproductive disorders such as pyometra and ovarian tumors, but in prevention of benign mammary tumors.

Monday, July 3, 2017

Surgical Removal of Screw Tail in Bulldogs

Case Report
Tank is a 7 year old male castrated English bulldog that presented for chronic skin fold dermatitis secondary to screw tail conformation.(Fig.1) 
Fig. 1: Tank, a 7 year old male castrated English Bulldog
The dog was showing signs of pruritis and pain in the tail area for several months. Physical examination revealed patchy partial alopecia of the lateral trunk and evidence of pyoderma in the skin folds associated with an ingrown tail.(Fig.2)
Fig. 2: The tail on Tank showing the typical screw  tail conformation
Preoperative thoracic radiographs showed no significant abnormalities. A radiograph of the caudal spine showed a typical abnormal tail anatomy common in bulldogs.
(Fig. 3) 
Fig. 3: Lateral radiograph of the caudal vertebrae on Tank showing the
abnormal coccygeal vertebrae. (arrow)
Pre-anesthetic CBC and serum chemistry profile on Tank were within normal limits. 

Surgical Procedure
Under general anesthesia, Tank was placed in sternal recumbency and the tail and adjacent skin was clipped and prepared for aseptic surgery. The anal sacs were expressed and a purse string suture was placed in the anus to prevent fecal contamination of the surgical site. Intravenous cephazolin was administered as a prophylactic antibiotic. 

The surgery was begun by making a cranial to caudal incision dorsally over the base of the tail.(Fig. 4) 
Fig. 4: The caudectomy on Tank began with an incision over the  dorsal aspect of the tail.
The tissues were dissected down to the bone by blunt and sharp dissection. After the soft tissues were dissected off, the coccygeal vertebrae were severed with a bone cutter and rongeurs.(Fig. 5)
Fig. 5: Appearance of surgical site after severing the coccygeal vertebrae. Arrow
indicates the cut edge of the vertebrae on the portion of tail to be removed.
The tail was then removed by extending the skin incisions ventrally on each side until the tail was no longer attached to the body.(Fig. 6)
Fig. 6: Surgical site after complete removal of the tail. Note the  cut
edge of the coccygeal vertebrae on the body (white arrow), and cut
edge of the coccygeal vertebrae on the excised tail (black arrow).
Care was taken not to injure the rectum which is just ventral to the tail. A Jackson-Pratt closed suction drain was placed in the deep aspect of the incision prior to closure. For more information on Jackson Pratt drains see: Excess skin was removed, and the surgical wound was closed in several layers: deep tissues with 2-0 PDS simple interrupted, subcutaneous tissues with 3-0 Monocryl simple interrupted, and the skin with 3-0 Monocryl simple interrupted. The purse string suture was removed. (Fig. 7)
Completed caudectomy on Tank including placement of the Jackson-Pratt drain.
Postoperatively Tank was given supportive care consisting of intravenous fluids, analgesic therapy, incision care and drain maintenance. Tank was discharged from the hospital the following day. Tank’s drain was removed 3 days postoperatively, and examination by the referring veterinarian 10 days postoperatively found satisfactory healing of the incision and improvement of his clinical signs. A follow-up phone call to the owner 1 month after surgery found Tank to continue doing well with no further pruritis or evidence of infection in the tail area.

Intertriginous dermatoses, or skin fold pyoderma, is a well recognized disorder caused by excessive skin folds in various regions in dogs, such as nasal, lip, perivulvular, and the secondary to the screw-tail, or ingrown tail abnormality in bulldogs. Redundant skin in these areas leads to skin friction, excessive moisture, and poor air circulation. Trapped skin secretions are fertile ground for surface bacteria and yeast to establish infection. 

Medical treatment consisting of hair clipping, medicated soaps and shampoos, and topical and systemic antibiotics may improve the condition, but surgical resection of the excessive skin is necessary to achieve successful long-term resolution. In bulldogs with ingrown tail, amputation of the tail is the most effective method of treating this form of intertriginous dermatoses. However, detailed descriptions of the technique for removal of the very abnormal bulldog tail are not widely available in the veterinary literature. 

Postoperative complications after caudectomy for ingrown tail were analyzed in one clinical study of 17 dogs. (1) Short-term complications were rare but included postoperative wound infection and changes in defecation behavior. Long-term complications were not seen and the authors stated that the procedure effectively resolved clinical signs in the dogs studied. 

1. Knight SM1, Radlinsky MG, Cornell KK, Schmiedt CW. Postoperative complications associated with caudectomy in brachycephalic dogs with ingrown tails. J Am Anim Hosp Assoc. 2013 Jul-Aug;49(4):237-42.